Monday, December 18, 2023

CSI meets agriculture: WSDA's pathology lab leads next-gen pest detection

Telissa Wilson
WSDA Plant Pathology and Molecular Diagnostics Lab

Northern giant hornets in vials awaiting testing.
Did you know WSDA’s Plant Pathology & Molecular Diagnostics Lab (PPMDL) uses cutting-edge molecular tools to detect unwanted pests and pathogens? Our PPMDL lab runs tests and uses equipment that many of you have probably seen on CSI or heard about in recent years due to COVID-19. PPMDL tests a wide variety of materials and runs an even wider array of tests, all with the shared goal of finding pests early and preventing them from being established. 

Like a forensic lab, PPMDL maintains highly trained staff, follows strict quality control measures, contributes to research and development of detection tools, and often collaborates with a wide array of organizations. Below is a snapshot of some recent work that showcases PPMDL projects straight out of a CSI episode.

Haplotyping invasive weeds

Sometimes it can be difficult to differentiate between species - whether it is a weedy plant or an invasive insect. Is this species a crime suspect or victim? Haplotyping compares genetic information among different samples to better understand how closely the samples are related - whether it is a native species or a wolf in sheep's clothing. 

Enter suspect number 1:  the highly invasive, aquatic grass Phragmites australis. Because the different subspecies of Phragmites grass are so difficult to tell apart visually, their haplotypes are used to assign them a native or non-native status, which is needed to guide treatment plans. 

For this work, PPMDL staff first extract DNA from submitted leaf samples. Then staff use a process called Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) to copy the DNA of very specific regions- regions that have been empirically determined to be good markers for haplotyping in a given species. The last step requires sequencing of the resulting PCR product so the sample haplotypes can be compared against a database of known haplotypes. In the case of Phragmites australis, haplotyping has allowed wetland managers across multiple agencies to preserve their native grass stands and only destroy the invaders. In our CSI analogy, you could say that haplotyping ensures that only the true perpetrator - Phragmites australis – does time for the crime. 

Forensic swabbing for trace DNA

Forensic swabbing can detect
where a pest has been. 
One of the biggest challenges in preventing the establishment of an invasive species is detecting the pest very soon after it is introduced. Sometimes WSDA receives reports of suspected invasive species, but the specimen was not collected and a determination cannot be made if a photo was provided. But what if you didn’t need a specimen – or even a photo – to confirm that a pest had been at a particular location?

You have probably seen shows where crime scenes are swabbed for the presence of DNA left behind on surfaces. These swabs are then shipped to a forensic lab, where scientists extract DNA and perform various molecular tests to analyze the sample. Even though forensic scientists have been utilizing trace DNA for decades to confirm presence at a crime scene, using trace DNA to detect agricultural pests is in its infancy. 

eDNA

Our pathology lab is changing that. PPMDL has been using swabs to collect environmental DNA (eDNA) left behind by two invasive insects – the spotted lantern fly (SLF) and the northern giant hornet (NGH). Once validated, these assays can confirm the presence of SLF and NGH at sites where a physical sample cannot be collected and early on before pest density is high enough to use alternative survey methods.

Pathogen detection

An exponential curve corresponds
to positive detection in a qPCR test
When someone passes away and the cause of death is unknown, forensic scientists may test for the presence of certain pathogens. PPMDL uses these same molecular methods to test for plant pathogens that threaten our state’s numerous agricultural resources. Quantitative Polymerase Chain Reaction (qPCR) is a highly specific and sensitive method that PPMDL routinely uses. In fact, PPMDL ran over 2,500 qPCR tests for plant pathogens alone in 2022! These test results help clear exports for trade, certify growing areas free of pests, and help prevent the establishment of high-risk pests through early detection surveys. 

DNA analysis of fecal samples

PPMDL conducts fecal analysis
to determine hornets' diet
One of the strangest-sounding projects that PPMDL has taken on recently involved extracting DNA from giant hornet fecal pellets to discover what the larvae were being fed here in Washington. To do this, PPMDL scraped fecal pellets from inside combs of the four nests that the WSDA Pest Program eradicated. They then extracted the total DNA, which theoretically contains traces of DNA from each organism that was fed to the larval hornet. Next, PPMDL used PCR to amplify a universal genetic segment (called the COI barcoding region) found in all insects and animals. Using advanced molecular magic (aka indexed metabarcoding) PPMDL was able to obtain thousands of genetic sequences that could be correlated to specific prey species. This work allowed researchers to see what NGH has been eating in Whatcom County and how that contrasts with diets in its native habitats. 

What did we find? Well, many folks have heard that northern giant hornets are a major threat to honey bees, but many other pollinators were also on their menu. PPMDL also found that bald-faced hornets made up a majority of the sequences obtained across all nests. Check out this "Wings menu" our Communications folks put together showing some of what they were eating. 

fake menu of what hornets eat

Learn more: